Volume 1: Beyond the Horizon: Canada's Interests and Future in Aerospace – November 2012

Part 2
Context (continued)

Chapter 2.2
Global Trends

The Canadian aerospace industry is subject to rapidly evolving global conditions that will affect market and production realities for the next 20 to 30 years. To ignore these factors, or to respond to them inadequately or belatedly, is to place our industry and its contributions to Canada's wealth and security at risk.

The most important trends include:

  • Global rebalancing. We are witnessing a rapid rise in the economic and geopolitical power of regions and countries other than those that dominated during the second half of the 20th century. North America, Europe, and Japan are being joined by China, Russia, Brazil, India, and other rising powers across Asia, the Middle East, Latin America, and Africa. Many of these countries are populous, geographically large, geopolitically ambitious, and willing to use state power and resources to build sectors considered to have strategic importance.
    Figure 5: Share of world GDP—2000 to 2020
    Figure 5: Share of world GDP - 2000 to 2020

    Description of Figure

    This line chart shows the projected evolution of the share of global gross domestic product (GDP) from 2000 to 2020 for the United States, the European Union, China, India, Brazil and Canada. The share of the Chinese economy has risen rapidly from less than 4% of global GDP in 2000 to about 10% in 2011, and is projected to reach almost 20% in 2020. During this period, the shares of the United States and the European Union are projected to decline steadily. The share of the United States peaked at 32% in 2001 and is projected to fall to under 17% by 2020. Similarly, the share of the European Union peaked at 31% in 2004 and is projected to decline to under 21% by 2020. China's economy is projected to become larger than the U.S. economy by 2018 and almost reach the size of the European Union by 2020. The shares of India and Brazil are also rising, but at a much slower pace. By 2020, India is projected to represent almost 6% of global GDP while Brazil should rise to almost 4%. Canada's share is declining slightly and should fall below 2% by 2020.

    Source: IHS Global Insight.
    GDP = gross domestic product
  • The hunger for natural resources and agricultural production. As hundreds of millions of people move from a rural, subsistence existence to more urban, middle class lifestyles, there are significant increases in the demand for fuel, the raw materials from which consumer goods are manufactured, water, and food.

    Figure 6: World energy consumption—1990 to 2035

    Figure 6: World energy consumption - 1990 to 2035

    Description of Figure

    This stacked bar chart shows the projected growth of world energy consumption until 2035. In 1990, member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) consumed about 200 quadrillion British thermal units (Btu) of energy, while the rest of the world consumed about 155 Btu. By 2008, consumption in OECD countries had been surpassed by the rest of world (244 vs. 260 quadrillion Btu). By 2035, consumption by OECD countries is expected to have grown only slightly, to 288 quadrillion Btu, while consumption in the rest of the world will have almost doubled 2008 levels, to reach 482 quadrillion Btu.

    Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration
    OECD = Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
  • Climate change and environmental concerns. Rising concern about the effects of climate change and other environmental issues—including air quality and noise pollution—are driving changes in consumer behaviour, regulatory agendas, and corporate conduct around the world.

Decrease in Arctic sea ice, 1979 and 2011

Sea ice extent
September 1979 (7.2 million km2)
Sea ice extent, September 1979
September 2011 (4.6 million km2)
Sea ice extent, September 2011
Source: Adapted from an image by Matt Savoie, National Snow and Ice Data Center, University of Colorado, Boulder, using SSM/I data overlaid onto the NASA Blue Marble.
  • The decline in defence expenditures and advent of non-conventional security threats. In a climate of fiscal restraint, Western countries are reducing defence budgets while national security planners focus increasingly on managing non-conventional threats as well as the risks of traditional war.
  • The digital revolution. We are in the middle of an epochal communications transformation driven by exponential increases in computing power, the advent of wireless technology, and an explosion of social media. The economic, social, and political impacts are already profound—and they are just beginning.
  • An aging population. Shifting demographics are creating new challenges—and necessitating new strategies—for companies that rely on a highly educated, highly skilled workforce.

These trends have significant implications for the global and Canadian aerospace industry.

Global rebalancing has accelerated the globalization of the industry itself. Although neither an entirely new phenomenon nor one restricted to aerospace, transnational production chains—where systems and components are built on many continents and brought together for assembly at one of several sites—have gone from novelty to norm as new entrants have established increasingly advanced manufacturing bases. In part, the globalization of aircraft production reflects a simple competitive imperative, with aircraft manufacturers shopping the world for suppliers offering the most technologically advanced products at the best prices. But it also reflects market access considerations, as local production can sometimes be an advantage—if not a prerequisite—for a firm hoping to make sales in growing markets.

And markets are growing, notwithstanding global economic uncertainty. According to Boeing's forecasts, approximately 34,000 new commercial planes worth $4.5 trillion will be required by airlines over the next two decades. Half of these sales will take place in the emerging markets of Asia—particularly China and, to a lesser extent, India—the Middle East, and Latin America. In all these regions, increasing wealth will fuel strong growth in business, leisure, and cargo air traffic.

Ascendant nations are not content just to be parts suppliers for, and customers of, the global aerospace business; they are determined to become aerospace powers themselves, and have invested massively in their industries to make this happen. This means additional competition for established aerospace nations. These new players benefit from comparatively low domestic production costs and are rapidly catching up to Western companies in terms of technological sophistication. Russia, for example, is making the Superjet 100, an aircraft in the regional jet market segment that Bombardier and Embraer currently dominate, while China's similarly sized ARJ21 is expected to enter into service in late 2013. Both projects have faced technical issues and delays, but Russia and China have redoubled their efforts, and each will roll out additional models over the next two decades. Other nations, from Ukraine to Mexico, are also making concerted bids to build their own planes or secure a position at the high-value end of global aerospace supply chains.

In short, for established aerospace powers like Canada, global rebalancing means new customers, new partners, and new competitors. This has created a more complex, dynamic market and production environment with a new and different set of risks and potential rewards.

Figure 7: Projected global deliveries of commercial airplanes, by region—2012 to 2031

Figure 7: Projected global deliveries of commercial airplanes, by region – 2012 to 2031

Projected deliveries

Description of Figure

This horizontal bar chart shows that the Asia-Pacific region is expected to receive the most deliveries of commercial airplanes between 2012 and 2031, with an estimated 12,000 airplanes. The second largest number of deliveries is expected in Europe (about 7,800 airplanes), followed by North America (about 7,300), Latin America (2,500), the Middle East (almost 2,400), the Commonwealth of Independent States (1,100), and Africa (900).

Source: Boeing, Current Market Outlook 2012-2031.
Note: Commercial airplanes include large, twin-aisle and single-aisle airplanes, regional jets and freighters, but exclude business jets and turbo props.

If global rebalancing affects how and where planes are built and sold, climate change and environmental concerns are reshaping the planes themselves. Airlines must deal with ever-tighter emissions standards, high fuel prices, and public reactions to contrails in the sky and noise in cities. In a business where margins are thin and regulations strict, the demand is for lighter, more aerodynamic aircraft designs and quieter, more fuel-efficient engines.

Emerging global conditions, climate change, and evolving government priorities are also leading to the opening of polar regions, particularly Canada's North, spurring resource extraction and other development in places that are not easily accessible by land or sea. A range of aircraft—from short-takeoff-and-landing turboprops to modern airships—may prove to be the best, or only, option for transporting personnel and equipment to these areas, particularly as the permafrost melts and surface transportation becomes increasingly difficult and costly. In addition, companies seeking to locate natural resources will require both piloted aircraft and drones to survey vast uninhabited areas. As the economy grows and communities expand in the North, there will also be an increasing need for activities related to the protection of people, property, and the environment—for which aerospace technologies, products, and services are particularly well-suited, given the geography and topography of this region.

In contrast to the positive growth projections for civil aerospace markets, the military aerospace segment faces reductions in defence expenditures. The United States and the European Union, which together account for almost two-thirds of global military spending, are paring military budgets as a result of fiscal pressures. Shrinking demand for military aerospace products could spill over to the civil sector, as companies are often active in both segments and use technologies developed for military purposes to improve their commercial offerings.

The emerging security environment also means that governments are looking for new equipment to address non-conventional security threats. These threats include the activities of small, secretive, militant groups, and require more effective surveillance of borders and oceans, and an ability to strike quickly, with precision, in far-flung locations. Aerospace technologies are vital to meeting these needs: witness, for example, the rapid expansion in the use of increasingly capable, and comparatively inexpensive, drones.

The increasing use of drones

More and more nations, including Canada, are operating unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), or drones, for commercial and military purposes. The U.S. Department of Defense's inventory of drones increased from 167 in 2002 to nearly 7,500 in 2010.

Canada's Department of National Defence currently operates a number of drones such as the Heron and the ScanEagle, which are being used for a wide array of applications including coastal patrol, mapping, and intelligence gathering. In addition, high-tech drones are being tested at Defence Research and Development Canada's Suffield, Alberta, facility for future use by Canada's military.

Drones are also being used in the Prairies to monitor crop health, such as nutrient and moisture levels, and by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police for crash site investigations. Future applications include enhanced monitoring of oil and gas pipelines and Canada 's borders.

Sources: Ed Wolski, Unmanned Aircraft Systems, "OUSD (AT&L) Unmanned Warfare," briefing, January 9, 2009; and Dyke Weatherington, "Current and Future Potential for Unmanned Aircraft Systems, OUSD (AT&L) Unmanned Warfare," briefing, December 15, 2010.
Photo of ScanEagle
The Boeing ScanEagle.
Source: Boeing.
Photo of Aeryon Scout
Aeryon ScoutTM micro-UAV.
Source: Aeryon Labs Inc.
Figure 8: Age profiles of workers of the Canadian aerospace manufacturing industry and all Canadian industries—2011
Figure 8: Age profiles of workers of the Canadian aerospace manufacturing industry and all Canadian industries – 2011

Description of Figure

This bar chart compares the percentage of employees of the aerospace manufacturing industry with the entire Canadian economy within each of the following age groups: 15-24, 25-34, 35-44, 45-54, and 55 and over. The chart shows that 31% of aerospace manufacturing employees are between 45 and 54, while another 22% are 55 and over. In comparison, 25% of employees for all Canadian industries are between 45 and 54 and 18% are 55 and over. The aerospace manufacturing sector also has fewer younger employees, with only 4% of workers aged between 15 and 24, compared with 14% across all industries. These numbers indicate that the aerospace manufacturing workforce is older than the overall Canadian workforce.

Source: Statistics Canada.
Whatever the segment in which an aerospace firm is active, it relies heavily on a well-educated and productive workforce. The demographic profile of workforces in most established aerospace nations suggests a wave of retirements in the coming decades, which could make it challenging for companies to maintain production capacity at a time when emerging aerospace countries, most with relatively young workforces, are steadily closing the skills gap. Even with a sufficient number of graduates, firms will need to adapt to the reality of experienced employees being replaced by fresh talent with limited experience.

These broad global developments are transformative. They mean more opportunities, but also more risks—and they establish a new global context in which the aerospace industry must meet tougher standards of performance to achieve competitive success. If Canadian companies, academic and research institutions, unions, and governments are clear-eyed and resolute in navigating these emerging conditions, the sector can emerge stronger. A weak or ambivalent response, however, could mean irreversible losses to the industry and the country.